Skip to content

Independent rankings

Beauty brand rankings

Every brand scored out of 10 on quality, value, ingredients, shade range, sustainability, packaging, delivery and support.

Some links on this page earn us a commission. It never changes a score. How we make money

Showing 17 of 17 brands

#1Best overall$

CeraVe

Ceramide-led basics developed with dermatologists, priced like commodities

4.64.6 out of 5Best for barrier repair, and anyone whose skin has been wrecked by actives
  • Three essential ceramides plus hyaluronic acid
  • Fragrance-free across most of the range
  • The cheapest genuinely good moisturiser in skincare
Easy returnsParaben-freeFragrance-free optionsNon-comedogenic options
CeraVe logo8.8TrustScore /108.8 out of 10 — Excellent
#2Best value$

The Ordinary

Clinical actives at commodity prices — the brand that reset what skincare is allowed to cost

4.44.4 out of 5Best for experienced users who already know which active they need
  • The lowest cost per active in skincare
  • Certified cruelty-free (PETA) and fully vegan
  • Concentrations and formats fully disclosed
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeParaben-freeFragrance-free options
The Ordinary logo8.7TrustScore /108.7 out of 10 — Excellent
#3Best for sensitive skin$$

La Roche-Posay

The best sunscreens in the western market, wrapped in a range built for reactive skin

4.54.5 out of 5Best for sensitive, reactive and rosacea-prone skin — and sunscreen, above all
  • Advanced EU sunscreen filters
  • Fragrance-free sensitive-skin lines
  • Pharmacy availability worldwide
Easy returnsParaben-freeFragrance-free optionsNon-comedogenic options
La Roche-Posay logo8.6TrustScore /108.6 out of 10 — Excellent
#4$$

Paula's Choice

Evidence-first formulations from the brand that made ingredient transparency a business model

4.44.4 out of 5Best for people who want the research cited before they buy
  • Fragrance-free across the whole range
  • Research cited on every product page
  • 60-day returns on opened product
Cruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-freeFragrance-free options
Paula's Choice logo8.5TrustScore /108.5 out of 10 — Excellent
#5Most popular$$$

Fenty Beauty

The brand that made a 50-shade foundation range the industry's minimum standard

4.34.3 out of 5Best for finding a genuine foundation match, particularly in deep and olive tones
  • 50+ shade foundation range
  • Cruelty-free
  • Industry-leading shade matching
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsOnline shade finder
Fenty Beauty logo8.4TrustScore /108.4 out of 10 — Excellent
#6$

Naturium

Well-dosed actives in textures that do not feel like a compromise, at mid-drugstore prices

4.44.4 out of 5Best for getting Ordinary-level actives without the Ordinary textures
  • Concentrations printed on the pack
  • Actives that feel good to use
  • Cruelty-free
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-free
Naturium logo8.3TrustScore /108.3 out of 10 — Excellent
#7Best for damaged hair$$

Olaplex

The bond-repair chemistry that created a haircare category, still the reference for damaged hair

4.34.3 out of 5Best for bleached, coloured or heat-damaged hair that has lost its structure
  • Patented bond-repair chemistry
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • No.3 is a genuine category-definer
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-free
Olaplex logo8.3TrustScore /108.3 out of 10 — Excellent
#8Best for beginners$

The INKEY List

Single-active skincare with plain-English labels — the beginner-friendly answer to The Ordinary

4.34.3 out of 5Best for learning what each active does without a chemistry degree
  • Plain-English ingredient labelling
  • Cruelty-free
  • Free advice service before you buy
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-free
The INKEY List logo8.2TrustScore /108.2 out of 10 — Excellent
#9$

Real Techniques

Brushes that outlast brands charging five times more, with almost no shedding

4.44.4 out of 5Best for a complete brush kit that survives years of washing
  • Minimal shedding
  • Vegan synthetic bristles
  • Years of durability at drugstore prices
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsShips internationally
Real Techniques logo8.1TrustScore /108.1 out of 10 — Excellent
#10$

e.l.f. Cosmetics

Fast-follower makeup at drugstore prices, with a vegan and cruelty-free range throughout

4.24.2 out of 5Best for getting a prestige-makeup look without prestige pricing
  • Fully vegan range
  • Leaping Bunny certified
  • Prestige performance at drugstore prices
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsLoyalty / rewards programme
e.l.f. Cosmetics logo8.0TrustScore /108.0 out of 10 — Excellent
#11$$$

Rare Beauty

Ultra-pigmented cream formulas with the best one-handed packaging in makeup

4.24.2 out of 5Best for cream blush, and anyone who needs accessible packaging
  • Accessibility-led packaging
  • Cruelty-free and vegan
  • Cream formulas that read as skin
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returns30+ shade range
Rare Beauty logo7.9TrustScore /107.9 out of 10 — Very good
#12$$

Phlur

Modern fragrance sold without the mystique — full notes, real longevity claims, no celebrity theatre

4.14.1 out of 5Best for buying fragrance online without smelling it first
  • Full note transparency
  • Honest longevity claims
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsSamples with orders
Phlur logo7.9TrustScore /107.9 out of 10 — Very good
#13$$$

K18

Peptide bond repair in four minutes, with a price per use that asks you to care about the time saved

4.24.2 out of 5Best for badly damaged hair where a single treatment needs to do a lot
  • Four-minute leave-in treatment
  • Peptide keratin repair
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeParaben-freeSulphate-free
K18 logo7.8TrustScore /107.8 out of 10 — Very good
#14$$

Sol de Janeiro

A body-care brand that sells a scent so distinctive people buy the cream to smell of it

4.24.2 out of 5Best for a body cream you will genuinely look forward to using
  • Signature pistachio and salted caramel scent
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Excellent absorbing texture
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-free
Sol de Janeiro logo7.6TrustScore /107.6 out of 10 — Very good
#15PartnerPaid partnership$$

Beautyblender

The sponge that invented the category, still good, and no longer worth the premium

3.93.9 out of 5Best for the most seamless blend, if replacement cost is not a concern
  • Category-defining blend quality
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Best-in-class taper and rebound
Fully vegan rangeCruelty-freeEasy returnsShips internationally
Beautyblender logo7.3TrustScore /107.3 out of 10 — Very good
#16$$

Glossier

A brand that sold an aesthetic better than it sold formulations

3.93.9 out of 5Best for a minimal, sheer, no-makeup look
  • Boy Brow and Cloud Paint
  • Cruelty-free
  • Strong direct retail experience
Cruelty-freeEasy returnsShips internationally
Glossier logo7.2TrustScore /107.2 out of 10 — Very good
#17PartnerPaid partnership$$$

Drunk Elephant

Well-made actives at prices that are very hard to defend against the competition

3.93.9 out of 5Best for someone who has the budget and wants a curated, fragrance-free routine
  • Fragrance-free prestige range
  • Cruelty-free
  • Airless pump packaging
Cruelty-freeEasy returnsParaben-freeFragrance-free options
Drunk Elephant logo7.0TrustScore /107.0 out of 10 — Very good
Newsletter

One email a week. Only the codes worth using.

New brand reviews, restocked discount codes and the launches worth your money. Unsubscribe in one click.

No spam, no selling your address. Ever.